This information provided by Operation Firing For Effect Research Department.

Source; Library of Congress; Congressional Record

Compiled by; Simon Alvarado  - OFFE Texas Director of Operations

thunder1970@juno.com

NOTE: This is the history of the Federal Law we now know as; USC, Title 38, 5301.

________________________________________________________________

TWENTIETH CONGRESS.  Sess. 1 CH 55 1828

 

CHAP. LIII – An Act for the relief of certain surviving officers and soldiers of the army of the revolution.

 

Sec. 4. And be it further enacted, That the pay allowed by this act shall, under the direction of the Secretary Treasury, be paid to the officer or soldier entitled thereto, or to their authorized attorney, as such places and days as said secretary may direct; and that no foreign officer shall be entitled to said pay, nor shall any officer or soldier receive the same, until he furnish to said secretary satisfactory evidence that he is entitled to the same conformity to the provisions of this act; and the pay allowed by this act shall not, in any way, be transferable or liable to attachments, levy, or seizure, by any legal process whatever, but shall inure wholly to the personal benefit of the officer or soldier entitled to the same by this act.

 

Approved May 15, 1828

 _______________________________________________________

 

SEVENTY CONGRESS.  SESS. 510 August 12, 1935

 

SEC. 3 Payments of benefits due or to become due shall not be assignable, and such payments made to, or on account of, a beneficiary under any of the laws relating to veterans shall be exempt from taxation, shall be exempt from the claims of creditors, and shall not be liable to attachments, levy, or seizure by or any legal or equitable process whatever, either before or after receipt by the beneficiary, Such provisions shall not attach to claims of the United States arising under such laws nor shall the exemption herein contained as to taxation extend to the property purchased in part  or wholly out of such payments.   Section 4747 of the revised Statutes and section 22 of the World War Veterans Act, 1924, are hereby repealed, and all other Acts inconsistent herewith are hereby modified accordingly.  The provisions of this section shall not be construed to prohibit the assignment by any person, to whom converted insurance shall be payable under Title III of the World War Veterans’ Act, 1924, of his interest in such insurance to any other member of the permitted class of beneficiaries.

 

1.       Twentieth Congress under Session I Chapter LIII – An Act for the relief of certain surviving officers and soldiers of the army of the revolution.

Section 4 that the “pay under this act shall not, in way, be transferable or liable to attachment, levy, or seizure, by any legal process whatever, but shall inure wholly to the benefit of the officer or soldier entitled to the same by this act.”  Approved, May 15, 1828 (From the Library of Congress)

 

2.       It was the intent of the Seventy Fourth Congress Chapter 510; An Act- To safeguard the estates of veterans derived from payments of pension, compensation, emergency officers’ retirement and insurance, and other purposes.  Section 3.

 

“Payments of benefits due or to become due shall not be assignable, and such payments made to, or on account of, a beneficiary under any of the laws relating to veterans shall be exempt from taxation, shall be exempt from the claims of creditors, and shall not be liable to attachment, levy, or seizure by or any legal or equitable process whatever, either before or after receipt by the beneficiary.”  Approved August 12, 1935

 

3.      It was the intent of the Eighty Fifth Congress (1958) Volume 72 Part I; An Act To consolidate into one act all of the laws by the Veterans Administration, and for other purposes.   (Data from the Library of Congress)

§3101.   Nonassignability and exempt status of benefits

(a)    Payments of benefits due or become due under any law administered by the Veterans Administration should not be assignable except to the extent specifically authorized by law, and such payments made to, or on account of, a beneficiary shall be exempt from taxation, should be exempt from the claims of creditors and shall not be liable to attachment, levy, or seizure by or under any legal or equitable process whatever, either before or after receipt by the beneficiary.  The preceding sentence shall not apply to claims of the United States arising under such laws nor shall the exemption therein contained as to taxation extend to ant property purchased in part or wholly out of such payments. The provision of this section shall not be construed to prohibit the reassignment of insurance otherwise authorized under Chapter 20 of this title, or of Servicemen Indemnity.

 

(b)    This section shall prohibit the collection setoff, or otherwise out of any benefits payable pursuant to any law administered by the Veterans Administration and relating to veterans, their estate, or their dependents, of any claim of the United States, or any agency thereof against (1) any person other than the indebted beneficiary or his estate; or (2) any

 

beneficiary or his estate except amounts due the United States by such beneficiary or his estate by reason of overpayments or illegal payments made under such law to such beneficiary or his estate or to his dependents as such. If the benefits referred to in the preceding sentence are insurance payable by reason of yearly renewable term insurance, United States Government Life Insurance, or national Service Life Insurance issued by the United States, the exemption provided in this section shall not apply to indebtedness existing against the particular insurance

(c)    contract upon the maturity of which the claim is based, whether such indebtedness is in the form of liens to secure unpaid premiums, or loans, or interest of such premiums or loans or indebtedness arising from overpayments of dividends, refunds, or other insurance benefits. Notwithstanding subsection (a), payments of benefits under laws administered by the Veterans Administration shall not be exempt from levy under subchapter D of Chapter 64 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954 (relating to seizure of property for collection of taxes).

 

3101.      See above

3102.      Waiver of recovery of overpayments

3103.      Certain bars to benefits

3104.      Prohibition against duplication of benefits

3105.      Waiver of retired pay

3106.      Renouncement of rights to benefits

3107.      Apportionment of benefits

3108.      Withholding benefits of persons in territory of the enemy

3109.      Payment of certain withheld benefits

Definitions of wholly (adv)

whol·ly [ hlee ]   Audio player

  1. completely and entirely: totally and in every way or to the fullest extent.

solely and exclusively: solely and to the exclusion of all other things.

 

Protection of Veteran’s Benefits from Third Party Attachment Dates Back to Post Revolutionary War!

 

According to documents uncovered during a recent search of the U.S Library of Congress, it was never the intent of Congress to allow anyone access to veteran’s benefits, under any circumstances. The following excerpt from the TWENTIETH CONGRESS (1828) support this argument. 

(Source: U.S. Congressional Record / Library of Congress)

CHAP. LIII – An Act for the relief of certain surviving officers and soldiers of the army of the revolution. [Approved May 15, 1828]

Sec. 4. And be it further enacted, That the pay allowed by this act shall, under the direction of the Secretary Treasury, be paid to the officer or soldier entitled thereto, or to their authorized attorney, as such places and days as said secretary may direct; and that no foreign officer shall be entitled to said pay, nor shall any officer or soldier receive the same, until he furnish to said secretary satisfactory evidence that he is entitled to the same conformity to the provisions of this act; and the pay allowed by this act shall not, in any way, be transferable or liable to attachment, levy, or seizure, by any legal process whatever, but shall inure wholly to the personal benefit of the officer or soldier entitled to the same by this act.

 

Below is another historical reference to ‘protection of veterans’ benefits’ discovered by the OFFE research team.

 

SEVENTY CONGRESS.  SESS. 510 August 12, 1935

 

SEC. 3 Payments of benefits due or to become due shall not be assignable, and such payments made to, or on account of, a beneficiary under any of the laws relating to veterans shall be exempt from taxation, shall be exempt from the claims of creditors, and shall not be liable to attachments, levy, or seizure by or any legal or equitable process whatever, either before or after receipt by the beneficiary,

 

As you can see, this issue is not a new idea; Congress has addressed ‘protection of veteran’s benefits’ several times over the centuries. In fact, the laws protecting veteran’s benefits are some of the oldest laws on the books, and date back to our founding fathers and the War of 1812.

 

The search of Congressional Records is a part of a 7 year study conducted by members of Operation Firing For Effect, the grassroots veteran’s advocacy group headquartered in Walworth, New York. OFFE Texas Director of Operations, Simon Alvarado, and OFFE Iowa Director of Operations, Jerry Bohr are heading-up the OFFE 5301 research effort, and both Alvarado and Bohr continue to collect documents and other evidence to protect our disabled veterans.   

 

According to OFFE National Chairman, Gene Simes, combat disabled veterans are routinely stripped of their veteran’s disability benefits by civil divorce court judges nationwide everyday of the week. The OFFE team has also discovered State family courts in general have absolutely no respect for the disabled veteran, or their rights. Civil court judges do not recognize the Federal laws which protect our disabled veterans and their benefits. This unjust practice by divorce court judges has resulted in disabled veterans becoming homeless, and even suicidal.

 

Gene Simes summarized the 5301 situation like this; “When a combat disabled veteran falls on hard times, loses their job, their house, facing bankruptcy, experiencing failing health, emotionally unstable and going through a divorce, the feelings of hopelessness and helplessness can be overwhelming. When facing such hardships in life the one thing a disabled veteran should be able to count on are their military benefits – which in many cases they earned on the battlefield with their blood, sweat, and tears. It is at these low points in life when these disability benefits are needed the most, and when they can help the greatest. To allow anyone the ability to arbitrarily or ambiguously take these benefits from them is cruel and unjust. I honestly believe Congress wrote 5301 with all of this in mind. And our research supports that argument,” Simes added.

     

Last month, OFFE submitted a formal written request to California Congressman Bob Filner for a public hearing before the House Committee on Veterans Affairs to present 12 personal testimonies from disabled veterans (male, and female) directly affected by the 5301 issue. We are currently awaiting a reply from Congressman Filner’s office.

 

Although there have been several attempts to pass legislator through the General Assembly at the State levels (including the passing of SB285 in California), Gene Simes and the OFFE team are convinced that Congress is the only entity capable of correcting this problem, as it was Congress who wrote USC, Title 38 in the first place.

 

Operation Firing For Effect has been at the forefront of the national debate over ‘protection of veterans’ benefits’ for several years now. For more about this story, visit; ‘AREA 5301’, http://jerebeery.com/AREA%205301.htm